Steve Powell’s public flaunting of his missing daughter-in-law’s private, childhood journals proved to be a major miscalculation on his part.
He went on NBC’s “Today” show on July 14, 2011 to share his theory that Susan Powell had “absconded” to Brazil with another missing person, Steven Koecher. He showed the TV camera crew the journals, which he and his son Josh Powell had scanned, transcribed, annotated and started to publish online.
“Them coming forth with the media and letting the media into Steven Powell’s home was great,” retired West Valley City, Utah police detective Ellis Maxwell said. “I was like ‘Right on’ because that’s what I needed to get inside Steve’s house.”
Ellis had developed a close relationship with Pierce County Sheriff’s detective Gary Sanders in the year-and-a-half since Josh Powell had relocated from West Valley City, Utah to his father’s home in South Hill, Wash. The two detectives had collaborated on several prior operations connected to the disappearance of Josh’s wife, Susan, on Dec. 7, 2009.
“West Valley was calling the shots,” Gary said. “We were just the auxiliary team, I guess you might call it, assisting them.”
However, in August of 2011, Ellis provided Gary with the even more inside information about his investigation.
“Yes, we wanted Josh to see this on the news and see what he had to say about it.”Ellis Maxwell
Police planning documents obtained exclusively by Cold revealed that West Valley police had conceived of a major multi-state operation code-named “Operation Tsunami.” It hinged on the use of a court-authorized wiretap to monitor phone calls made and received on three phone lines: Josh Powell’s mobile, Steve Powell’s mobile and the landline at the Powell family home.
Ellis Maxwell declined to discuss specifics of the Tsunami plan when interviewed for Cold, citing a need to protect police tactics.
Tsunami was to include a series of coordinated events that would prompt discussion between Josh and Steve Powell, including a public search of abandoned mines near Ely, Nev. and a “Remember Me” honk-and-wave event in the area of Puyallup, Wash.
West Valley needed Pierce County’s assistance with perhaps the biggest piece of the Tsunami plan: a search warrant raid at the Powell house.
Gary’s search warrant affidavit spelled out why police believed Josh Powell had committed the crimes of murder, kidnapping and obstruction. It explained that Susan’s journals held potential evidence of those crimes, as they likely included her first-hand perspective on her relationship with Josh.
West Valley police had asked Josh and Steve Powell to voluntarily turn over the journals in November of 2010, a request which the father and son had refused.
“With the lack of cooperation and criminally obstructive behavior from Steven and Joshua Powell refusing to provide the journals to law enforcement,” Gary wrote, “a search warrant must be executed to recover this evidence and in addition, any and all digital copies.”
Susan’s journals were not the only target of the warrant affidavit. It also sought digital media, images or papers that might contain passwords for Josh’s encrypted files, photographs or videos, trace evidence and “any items determined to be evidence of the crimes listed” that would help detectives complete their investigation.
A Pierce County Superior Court judge issued the warrant on Aug. 24, 2011. West Valley police, with the assistance of Pierce County deputies, U.S. Marshals and FBI agents, served it the following day.
The Puyallup Raid
Ellis and Gary led the service of the warrant together. They and a team of more than 20 law enforcement officers swarmed the house at 18615 94th Ave. Court East in the early afternoon.
“Hot day,” Gary said. “I remember because the house didn’t have A/C and it was a huge house.”
Josh Powell was at home with his sons, Charlie and Braden, as well as two of his younger siblings, John and Alina Powell. The police ordered them all out of the house.
Steve Powell was not at home, having traveled to the Tri-Cities area of Washington to investigate a business opportunity.
Ellis declined to confirm if that business meeting was arranged by police, again refusing to discuss operational details.
“Maybe, maybe not,” Ellis said. “I don’t know if it was valid or not. I wasn’t there for that business meeting.”
However, the documents obtained by Cold revealed that business meeting was, in fact, part of the Tsunami plan.
The detectives told Josh he was free to leave, but they would not be able to release his minivan until they’d searched it. Josh, John, Alina and the boys waited in the yard.
“We were hoping to get some more information from Josh but he just, he wouldn’t talk to us,” Ellis said.
Josh also handed over a USB device, a “token” without which his desktop computer would not boot.
As soon as police completed a search of Josh’s minivan, he left the house.
House of Horrors
The detectives made a methodical, room-by-room search of the Powell family home.
Many of the rooms and hallways were clogged with clutter. Shelves of Steve Powell’s books lined the walls in many of the rooms.
“A hoarder is your biggest nightmare on a search warrant, just because you know you have to go through every item,” Gary Sanders said. “If you’re not being thorough, you’re not doing a good investigation.”
The main floor of the house held the kitchen, dining space, Steve’s office or music room, a back office space and the garage. All of the bedrooms in the house were on the upper level.
Josh’s bedroom was among the neatest in the house. Police found several interesting items there, including a multi-camera security system, draft documents for the susanpowell.org website and a banker’s box containing nine volumes of Susan’s childhood journals.
The camera system showed views of the front porch, the driveway and the side yard of the house. Its screen was positioned so that Josh could have monitored all of the live feeds simultaneously from his bed.
“I think he was starting to, he was getting worried,” Gary said. “They knew something was coming.”
Charlie and Braden shared a bedroom. It held a single futon, a children’s play table and a few toys. Steve Powell’s book collection took up most of the space in the boys’ room.
Alina’s bedroom held few items of interest, aside from her computers. Detectives observed that one of her laptops was powered on and logged in and appeared to be running file eraser and encryption software.
West Valley police detective Brad Hardinger located a wireless router in Alina’s bedroom and disconnected it to ensure no one could remotely log in to any of the machines on the network.
John Powell’s bedroom presented police a significant challenge. Stacks of boxes filled the floor. Clothing was scattered about, along with piles of used tissues. John’s art projects also caught the attention of detectives.
“It had a noose, had a giant paper pterodactyl that was hanging,” Gary said. “His drawings of swords through women’s vaginas, just weird depictions and stuff.”
Even more bizarre were collections of what appeared to be toenail clippings and a bag of hair.
“It was a house of horrors when we went through there,” Gary said.
They hadn’t even started going through Steve Powell’s bedroom.