Season 3: The Search for Sheree Warren

  • Who is Who

    Cold includes a large cast of real people. This is the place to go if you could use help keeping them straight. This list will be updated as new episodes drop.

    Read More
  • Ep 1: Everything Escalates

    An obscene caller sets up a “date” with an unwilling woman. Hear how she turns the tables on the man who threatens her husband and children.

    Read More
  • Ep 2: Go Ask Alice

    Sheree Warren seeks to escape and unhappy marriage. Her estranged husband makes a threat shortly before Sheree disappears.

    Read More
  • Ep 3: Cherish the Love

    Cary Hartmann uses access and influence to steer the search for Sheree Warren. But police are growing suspicious of Cary.

    Read More
  • Ep 4: The Supper Club

    A social group with a sinister side. Could a discovery about Cary Hartmann’s supper club have led to Sheree Warren’s disappearance?

    Read More
  • Ep 5: Nighthawk

    Sheree Warren’s boyfriend Cary Hartmann heads to trial in the Ogden City Rapist case. Old friends wonder what clues he might be hiding.

    Read More
  • Ep 6: Lying Liars

    Cary Hartmann hopes DNA will prove his innocence. But an informant tells police Cary might’ve buried Sheree Warren’s body next to a highway.

    Read More
  • Ep 7: Purgatory

    A witness places Cary Hartmann on a mountain behind Causey Reservoir just days after Sheree Warren’s disappearance.

    Read More
  • Ep 8: Fool Me Once

    A detective secures a Cary Hartmann interview. Cary’s answers don’t align with the evidence in the cold case disappearance of Sheree Warren.

    Read More
  • Ep 9: A Picture in the Lobby

    A new detective takes up the search for Sheree Warren. He conducts a new Charles Warren interview. But Sheree’s ex can’t clear himself.

    Read More
  • Ep 10: Last Man Standing

    Time runs short in the search for truth about the fate of Sheree Warren. One of two suspects dies, while the other invokes silence.

    Read More
  • Bonus: The Convenient Alternative

    Nancy Baird vanished on July 4, 1975. Investigators have long suspected Ted Bundy killed Baird. But the case files tell a different story.

    Read More
  • Bonus: The Causey Search

    A mound of rocks resembling a clandestine grave sends detectives into the hills near Causey Reservoir. COLD is there for the excavation.

    Read More

Stay in Touch

Email us tips

To subscribe to our email newsletter, send us your email address. We’ll let you know when there is something big happening with the case.

First Name
Last Name