Ep 4: Kicking the Hornet’s Nest


Nancy Baird’s son, Brant Baird, spent most of his life avoiding news articles, blog posts and documentaries that featured his missing mom. He didn’t know how to confront the emotions raised by all of the talk of Nancy being a victim of serial killer Ted Bundy.

“That’s what everyone thought,” Brant said. “I’ve never really gone down those rabbit holes.”

That changed in May of 2023, when a relative suggested Brant listen to an episode of COLD titled “The Convenient Alternative.”

“I listened to it a couple of times,” Brant said. “It was just a different take on it. It kind of painted a better picture of the overall story.”

For the first time in his life, Brant heard the details of the Nancy Baird case file, which had never before been public. The podcast provided new information about Ted Bundy having an alibi for the day Nancy Baird disappeared. It included audio recordings from Bundy’s January, 1989 interview with a police detective from Utah, in which Bundy denied any knowledge of Baird’s case.

Serial killer Theodore “Ted” Bundy appears outside a courtroom in Salt Lake City in November, 1975. Bundy was suspected, but never charged, in the disappearance of July 4, 1975 disappearance of Nancy Perry Baird. Photo: KSL-TV archive

“It did cause some doubt that he didn’t [kill Nancy],” Brant said. “Why would he not confess to it?”

The podcast episode also included clips from an interview with one of the police officers who first investigated the case: Tom Jackson. Hearing that, Brant realized he could no longer afford to keep his missing mom’s case at arm’s length.

“It was 51 years ago. Everybody’s getting older. We’re kind of at a point where if we are ever going to get an answer, it’s got to be fairly soon,” Brant said.

So, Brant reached out to COLD to learn what else might be done to advance the investigation.


Tom Jackson’s daughters react

Tom Jackson’s two daughters, Heidi Holmberg and Tori Riddle, reacted differently to hearing their father’s interview in the episode of COLD.

At one point in Jackson’s interview, he stated he wouldn’t be surprised if police considered him a suspect in Nancy Baird’s disappearance. Jackson said he was ok with that, because he frequently passed polygraph examinations as part of his annual sex offender registration updated in the state of Idaho.

“I was like, ‘Wow,'” Heidi said. “I mean, we know he’s a child molester but this is a whole other level. Like, do you think he could have really taken this woman?”

Heidi and Tori felt troubled, believing the podcast had under-represented the scope of Tom Jackson’s past sex abuse crimes. They worried that if police were investigating their father as a suspect in the Nancy Baird cold case, they might be lacking important context.

So, on May 23, 2023, Heidi met with a pair of Davis County Sheriff’s Office deputies in Farmington, Utah to talk about her dad, Tom Jackson.

“I was like, ‘Yeah we need to shine some light on him. Just look. If there’s nothing, there’s nothing,'” Heidi said. “Then, it spiraled.”

Detectives questioned Heidi about sexual abuse she’d experienced as a child. They conducted follow-up interviews with Heidi’s younger sister, Tori, who provided corroborating accounts of her own abuse.

“I handle this in a way that it is almost like it was somebody else that it happened to,” Tori said. “I’ve been dealing with it silently.”

The sheriff’s office also spoke to Geraldine O’Farrell, Heidi and Tori’s mother. Geraldine had been childhood friends with Nancy Baird. She’d been married to Tom Jackson during the summer of 1975, when Nancy disappeared and Tom worked the investigation as a police officer for the city of East Layton.

Geraldine O’Farrell speaks during at interview for COLD on December 19, 2025. O’Farrell was childhood friends with Nancy Perry Baird, and was married to former East Layton police officer Thomas “Tom” Jackson at the time Baird disappeared. Photo: Dave Cawley, KSL Podcasts

Geraldine told the investigators her ex-husband was manipulative and untruthful. She provided a list of 25 names of women and girls who she suspected Tom might’ve also abused.

“They contacted me quite a few times to try to see if I could find where these different people, who are now adults, were living,” Geraldine said, “like the girl who used to babysit for us and things like that.”


The pretext phone call

Heidi, Tori and Geraldine’s disclosures to deputies resulted in the Davis County Sheriff’s Office opening a new investigation surrounding the alleged child sex abuse. During a follow-up interview in June, a detective named Kurt Jemmett told Heidi the case was shaky because it amounted to a he-said-she-said situation.

Jemmett suggested they try to draw a confession out of Tom Jackson, who at the time was living in Buhl, Idaho.

“I thought we were going to drive out there,” Heidi said. “[Jemmett] goes, ‘Let’s try the phone call first and then see where we get.”

Heidi had not spoken to her father in 20 years. They hadn’t reconnected after Tom’s release from prison in Idaho in 2011, following his 15-year sentence for child sex crimes against other children. The idea of hearing Tom’s voice filled Heidi with dread.

“I wanted to throw up, but I was like, ‘Ok, let’s do it.'”

Tom didn’t answer Heidi’s initial call. It wasn’t until a day later that he and his daughter spoke. In a recording of the call obtained by Heidi and shared with COLD, Tom Jackson is heard saying, “Is this Heidi? Holy cow!”

Heidi told her father she was in therapy and her counselor suggested speaking with her abuser in order to get “closure.”

“I’ll tell you what I remember,” Tom is heard saying in the recording. “I would manipulate you into coming in while I was naked under the sheet.”

Over the course of the next 20 minutes, Tom Jackson made admissions using sometimes graphic language to acts of sexual abuse that he said began when Heidi was 3 or 4 years old.

Those admissions became the basis for a new set of criminal charges against Jackson. And they also opened the door for detectives to interview him as a person of interest in the cold case disappearance of Nancy Perry Baird.


Episode credits
Research, writing and hosting: Dave Cawley
Audio production and mastering: Aaron Mason
Cold main score composition: Michael Bahnmiller
KSL executive producer: Sheryl Worsley
KSL companion story: https://www.ksl.com/article/51633712/former-east-layton-police-officer-pleads-no-contest-to-child-sex-abuse-charges
Episode transcript: